Ever considered the AT-1?
I would not consider it as dark or dull, since it has lots of like something everyone refers to "complex harmonics". I can't describe it better. But there is no ice pick, and it is well rounded in the highs and upper mids, and the "main" mids sit just right to work perfectly with modern hot rodded Marshall tones.
It's just a very, very good sounding bridge pickup, for me it is THE bridge pickup, I like it even better than the Music Man Axis custom.
It may or may not be best suited for fast tuned down higain riffing, since this is not, what I play.