[quote author]
Now Darth I have a question for you: Your homebrewed RG lookalike with a Gotoh Floyd is on the thumbnail for the official Duncan JB video right? WHAT IS THAT GUITAR! TELL ME ABOUT IT!! That blue + carbon fiber pickguard + Gotoh look totally caught my eye!
Thanks for the interest. Sorry, but that's not my guitar.
I do like your take on how wood can be all over the place. I have a maple body that sound more like you'd expect alder to sound. I have mahogany that's thick and mahogany that's bright. I have one poplar body that's at least as bright as maple.
[/quote]
Haha yeah I've noticed wood to be inconsistent (organic material, surprise surprise). Making several bodies and necks out of the exact same tree can yield you parts that are completely different with weight distribution and even density, especially for porous woods. Like you I have several guitars made out of the same wood and I could never go "yup, that's the mahogany/alder/ash/basswood doing work", especially with mahogany. I have 2 Gibsons that are pretty much identical everywhere, and one is very bright sounding and spanky, the other is rather mellow and reminds me of a 335.
Now here's something that I've been thinking about, although probably impossible to achieve: what if we could run an experiment where you first take a piece of alder and a piece of mahogany, make them have the EXACT same weight distribution (x-ray it and make sure every damn inch has the same amount of solid wood tissue) and density, and see how they sound compared to each other. Now take 2 pieces of the same species of wood, but make sure they are cut from very different parts of the tree with different density, and see how they compare to each other. Finally you then compare if the "similar density" alder and mahogany sound more similar, or if the "both mahogany but different parts of the tree" mahogany pieces sound more similar.