I use 20 or so different amps and I'm an amp and guitar tech, so........
I know how they describe it, maybe with 9s or some other rubber band its that bright but I just do not hear it. There are other conventional humbuckers that are brighter, tighter, and more single-coil like.
If you really want single-coil like, get a Firebird pickup.
I've tried it over the years many times in many guitars, it just is not bright enough, tight enough, so qualify for single-coil like to me. I wish it was, and I wish DiMarzio would make something that was, but they do not.
It sounds like a low wind paf. It's not muddy, but it's not tight either, it's woody. The high end doesn't have enough edge to it to be in any sort of single coil category.
I honestly like it a lot more with ceramic, but you have to remove one of the spacers to get a normal size magnet in there. The stock pickup has a spacer on both coils and an under-sized A5.
I heard all that. My complaint isn't that it's not single coilish enough- you pick up a Strat if you want a Strat sound. My point of contention was that it's not transparent. It really dictates the sound of the guitar more than many others, and more than most PAFs.
I don't understand how it could sound like a typical low wind PAF when DiMarzio specifically designed it to be unlike a typical PAF. I've played lower wind older PAFs and they sound nothing like the HFH.
Re: my guitar, jeez...Tone Zone, Crunch Lab/Liquifire, HFH (both positions), Air Norton (both positions), Norton (both positions), PAF Master set (Bridge pickup tried in both positions), Fred (both positions), X2N, D-Activator X or whatever that thing's called, Dimebucker, JB, Jazz, 59 neck, SH-5 Custom, PAF Pro, Steve's Special, AT-1, FS-1...maybe forgetting a few.
Sent from my XT1080 using Tapatalk